Anchoring, the Cognitive Bias That Makes Us Rely Too Much on Initial Information

The Anchoring Bias in Sales and Marketing

The Cognitive Bias that influences our choices because we tend to put a disproportionate weight on an initial of information.

Bastian Moritz
Nov 2023

Understanding the influence of anchoring pertinent in many of our daily judgments and decisions is crucial for trying to make informed choices and for sales, marketing, or negotiation, where such biases can be leveraged or need to be guarded against.

In decision-making, we human beings are not always the perfectly rational agents that classical economic theories might suggest. Instead, various heuristics and biases can influence our judgments and choices. One such bias, central to numerous contexts ranging from financial decisions to judgements about uncertain events, is the concept known as "anchoring."

The Cognitive Bias That Makes Us Rely Too Much on Initial Information

Anchoring is a psychological heuristic or cognitive bias that describes the human tendency to rely too heavily to an initial piece of information (known as the "anchor") when making subsequent judgments or decisions.

We tend to put a disproportionate weight on an initial of information.

This means that once this anchor is set, other estimations or decisions are made by adjusting away from it and therefore influences subsequent judgments and perceptions, often in ways that might not be logically justifiable.

The initial information serves as a reference point even if the anchor itself is arbitrary or irrelevant to the task at hand.

Do you want green or red apples? Apple would be that first piece of information you react to; instead of questioning if you like apples or are hungry at all right now.

So the bias here is making judgments by adjusting away from that anchor, and interpreting other information around the anchor.

Instead, we should step back and ask us what the case at hand is: thinking from first principles in discussions or making conscious decisions in decision-making.

If you first see a T-shirt priced at $100 and later see a similar one priced at $60, you might perceive the second shirt as being cheap, even if it's still more expensive than what you'd usually pay.

While anchoring can significantly influence our judgments, its impact can vary:

Relevance of Anchor: If the anchor is entirely irrelevant to the task at hand, its influence might be diminished, though surprisingly, even seemingly irrelevant anchors can still exert some effect.

Expertise: Individuals with more expertise in a domain might be less susceptible to anchoring effects in that area because they have more knowledge to draw upon.

Awareness: Being aware of the anchoring effect can sometimes reduce its impact, though it's not always easy to correct for it consciously.

Anchoring can be a powerful tool across various domains, from marketing and sales to crafting effective customer-centric strategies. By recognizing its influence on human perception and decision-making, businesses can more effectively guide their interactions and offerings to resonate with their target audiences.

Applying the Anchoring Bias in Sales and Marketing

Anchoring is a powerful cognitive bias and can be a potent tool for marketers and sales professionals. When used ethically and judiciously, it can guide consumers towards making decisions that they're happy with. However, like all tools, its effectiveness depends on the context.

Sales and marketing professionals have long understood and leveraged the anchoring effect to influence consumers' purchasing decisions.

Effectively Anchoring in Marketing

In marketing, anchoring is used to shape consumers' perceptions of value, price, quality, and other product or service attributes.

A classic is anchoring by “Price Comparison” by showing the original price next to a discounted price marketers can make the discount seem more significant. The original price serves as the anchor, making the discounted price appear more attractive. Or making the sale price seem like a bargain, even if the sale price is still relatively high.

To increase "Perceived Value” Marketers might introduce a product with high-end features or a premium version first, establishing a high anchor for quality and price. When the standard version is subsequently released, consumers may perceive it as offering good value for its price, even if it's still relatively expensive.

Anchoring with "Comparative Advertising" Brands sometimes compare their products to more expensive competitors, even if the features aren't exactly comparable. The idea is to set the anchor with the more expensive product so that their own product seems like a value proposition.

Anchoring with "Product Features" is that each subsequent version of a product will be compared to the previous version. If a product is first introduced highlighting its most advanced features, those become the anchor. Later, as consumers assess other features, they might view them through the lens of the initial anchor, potentially perceiving them as better than they would in isolation.

Anchoring Strategies in Sales

In sales, anchoring can be a tactic to influence negotiations, pricing decisions, and the perceived value of a product or service.

In negotiations, the first number a.k.a. the "Initial Offer" that's put on the table often serves as an anchor. If a seller starts with a high price, even if they later offer a discount, the buyer's perception of what constitutes a "fair" price is influenced by that initial high number.

Anchoring for "Price Perception" works like this: If you were shopping for a watch and saw one priced at $2,000 but then found another one for $500, you might perceive the second watch as a bargain. However, if you had first seen a watch priced at $100, the $500 watch might seem expensive. In both cases, the first price you saw (either $2,000 or $100) serves as an anchor, influencing your perception of the $500 watch's value.

Software and service companies often offer products in basic, premium, and platinum tiers. That is the "Tiered Pricing" anchor where the highest tier, while expensive, serves as an anchor, making the middle tier look more appealing.

Similar happens when you go to a restaurant where you’ll always find "High-priced Items on Menus". Restaurants list a few very expensive items on their menu, making the rest of the items seem reasonably priced. Even if customers don’t order the most expensive item, the presence of that item can make them spend more than they would have otherwise. The price also might make you choose a product that has a higher margin. Aaand they are great at upselling you those extremely high margin fries and sugar waters…

"Package or Bundle Pricing" is another effective anchoring tactic where Sales teams offer products or services in bundles, with the total price of individual items serving as an anchor, making the bundle seem like a better deal.

"Upselling and Cross-selling" is similar to bundeling but you present the offers sequentially instead of as a package. By first introducing a higher-priced item and then presenting a complementary product at a lower price, salespeople can make the additional product seem like a minor additional expense in comparison that is perceived as a no-brainer.

Anchoring in a Customer-Centric Growth Strategy

A customer-centric growth strategy focuses on enhancing the customer experience, meeting customer needs, and ensuring customer satisfaction to drive business growth.

Anchoring can also be applied to First Impressions. Beyond pricing, anchoring can also affect how consumers view product features or benefits. If a product is introduced as "innovative" or "luxury", those initial descriptions can serve as anchors, influencing how subsequent features are perceived.

Setting Expectations acts as an anchor where the initial interaction a customer has with a brand often sets the tone for the entire relationship. If a company promises and delivers exceptional service in the first encounter, that becomes the anchor, influencing the customer's expectations and perceptions of subsequent interactions.

Expectations and perceptions also come from Product or Service Launches. When introducing a new product or service, businesses can use anchoring to shape how customers perceive its value. By first showcasing the most premium features or benefits, and then introducing the entire range, customers may perceive the overall offering as more valuable.

If customers provide feedback about a particular aspect of a product or service and the company addresses it promptly and effectively, that positive resolution can serve as an Feedback and Improvements anchor. It establishes the company's responsiveness and commitment to customer satisfaction, influencing how customers perceive future interactions.

Example for the Anchoring Effect

Imagine a tech company releasing a new smartphone. They have two primary models: a standard and a pro version. The standard version is priced at $700, while the pro version is priced at $1,200. The company also decides to release a limited "luxury" edition at $2,500, which has a few additional features and a unique design.

Most consumers might not be interested in the luxury edition, but its presence serves a purpose. Now, when customers compare the standard and pro versions, the pro doesn't seem as expensive relative to the luxury edition. The $1,200 for the pro version seems more reasonable when there's a model that costs more than double that amount. The luxury edition, in this case, serves as an anchor, pushing more people towards the pro version than if it were absent.

Implications and Considerations using Anchoring as Strategy

In conclusion, anchoring can be a potent tool for marketers.

By staying attuned to consumer awareness, adhering to ethical considerations, and understanding the competitive landscape, you can harness the power of anchoring effectively and ethically.

Consumer Awareness

As consumers become more aware of marketing tactics, they might become more resistant to obvious anchoring strategies. It's crucial for marketers to use this technique judiciously.

1. The Rise of the Informed Consumer With the proliferation of information available online, consumers today are more informed than ever. They have access to a plethora of resources, reviews, and comparisons at their fingertips. As a result, they are becoming more aware of marketing tactics, including anchoring.

2. Resistance to Obvious Tactics As consumers become more educated about these strategies, there's a risk they might become more resistant to obvious anchoring tactics. Overuse or blatant use of anchoring can lead to skepticism and mistrust. It's crucial for marketers to use this technique judiciously, ensuring it adds value to the consumer's decision-making process rather than manipulating it.

Ethical Considerations

Deliberately misleading consumers by creating false anchors or making unfair comparisons can be considered unethical and can harm a brand's reputation.

1. Transparency and Honesty While anchoring can be an effective strategy, it's essential to ensure that it's used transparently and honestly. Deliberately misleading consumers by creating false anchors or making unfair comparisons can be considered unethical.

2. Reputation and Trust Trust is a cornerstone of brand loyalty. Employing deceptive anchoring tactics can harm a brand's reputation, leading to long-term damage that might be difficult to repair. Brands should always prioritize building and maintaining trust with their consumers.

Competitive Landscape

If several competitors are using similar anchoring strategies, the effect can be diluted. It's crucial to understand the broader market context.

1. Saturation of Tactics In a market where several competitors are using similar anchoring strategies, the unique value and differentiation of the tactic can be diluted. This can lead to a scenario where consumers become indifferent to the anchors presented, rendering the strategy ineffective.

2. Understanding the Broader Context It's crucial for brands to understand the broader market context when employing anchoring. This includes being aware of how competitors are using the strategy and ensuring that their own approach stands out. Regular market research and competitor analysis can provide valuable insights in this regard.

3. Innovation and Evolution To stay ahead in the competitive landscape, brands should consider innovating and evolving their anchoring strategies. This could involve experimenting with different types of anchors, using technology to personalize anchors for individual consumers, or integrating anchoring with other marketing strategies for a more holistic approach.

Learn more about other cognitive biases and understand why we buy

How does the anchoring effect interact with other cognitive biases in a multi-faceted marketing strategy?

Anchoring can work in tandem with other biases. For instance, the "endowment effect" (where people value their possessions more than similar items they don't own) can be amplified with the right anchor. A product anchored as premium can make owners feel they possess something of higher value, increasing satisfaction and loyalty.

How does the anchoring effect differ across cultures or global markets?

Cultural norms and values can influence the susceptibility to the anchoring effect. For instance, cultures that place a high emphasis on negotiation might be more attuned to initial price anchors. Conversely, in markets where fixed pricing is the norm, consumers might be less influenced by discounts off an anchor price.

How does the anchoring effect relate to other cognitive biases in decision-making?

Anchoring is just one of many cognitive biases that influence decision-making. It often interacts with other biases like confirmation bias (favoring information that confirms existing beliefs) and availability heuristic (relying on immediate examples when evaluating something).

How can consumers guard against the anchoring effect when making purchasing decisions?

Consumers can guard against the anchoring effect by being aware of it and consciously evaluating the intrinsic value of a product or service. It's also helpful to compare prices and features across multiple brands and not just rely on the initial information provided.

You as a salesperson should help your prospect to do that if you want to be their trusted advisor.

Are there situations where anchoring might not work or even backfire?

Yes, if consumers perceive the anchor as unrealistic or manipulative, it can backfire. For instance, if a product is initially priced too high, consumers might view it as overpriced, and a subsequent discount might not change that perception. It might even become undesirable just like yesterday’s newspaper.

Can businesses use anchoring ethically?

Businesses can use anchoring ethically by ensuring that the anchors they set are truthful and relevant. For instance, showing the genuine original price next to a discounted price, rather than inflating the original price to make the discount seem larger. Your product is most likely not a “Veblen good”

Given the ethical considerations, are there regulatory frameworks that businesses should be aware of when employing anchoring strategies?

In many jurisdictions, misleading pricing strategies, including deceptive anchoring, can be subject to consumer protection laws. It's crucial for businesses to ensure that any anchoring strategy is transparent, fair, and in compliance with local regulations.

Are there industries or sectors where the anchoring effect is particularly pronounced or diminished?

The anchoring effect can be more pronounced in industries where products or services are less commoditized, and there's a greater range in pricing and perceived value. Luxury goods, real estate, and technology are examples. In contrast, highly commoditized markets, like staple foods, might see a diminished effect.

How does digital marketing and e-commerce amplify or mitigate the anchoring effect?

Digital platforms allow for dynamic pricing, which can amplify the anchoring effect by presenting different anchors to different consumers based on their browsing behavior. However, the transparency and ease of price comparison online can also mitigate the effect, as consumers can quickly validate the value of a deal.

With the rise of AI and machine learning in marketing, can businesses predict and optimize the anchoring effect for individual consumers?

Absolutely. Advanced analytics can predict which anchors are most effective for specific consumer segments. By analyzing past behavior, businesses can tailor their anchoring strategies to individual preferences, optimizing the perceived value and likelihood of purchase.

Ready? Set. Growth!
Learn about growing your organization and the impact of its mission and other insights & stories about Customer-centricity and Organic Growth: